How the U.S. Utilitarian Approach to IP Law Unleashes Creativity

Imagine a world without copyright or patent protections. Why would anyone invest time, resources, or creativity into building something new if they had no assurance of reward? Intellectual property (IP) law isn’t just a legal framework; it’s a dynamic tool designed to maximize societal benefit by incentivizing creators and innovators.

At the heart of the U.S. IP system lies a fascinating philosophy: utilitarianism. This principle emphasizes creating the greatest good for the greatest number by balancing the rights of creators with public access. Let’s dive into how this philosophy shapes copyright and patent law in the United States.

---

What’s the Big Idea Behind U.S. IP Law?

The foundation of U.S. IP law is enshrined in the Constitution. Article I, Section 8, Clause 8 grants Congress the power “to promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries.”

This single sentence reflects the utilitarian spirit: protect creators’ rights temporarily so society can ultimately benefit. The system ensures that creativity and innovation flourish while eventually enriching the public domain.

The case posed a key legal issue:

• Does using a patented invention on a foreign ship, temporarily in a U.S. port for commerce, infringe the rights of the U.S. patentee?

This issue arose when the plaintiff, Brown, accused Duchesne of infringing his patent. The alleged infringement? The use of a patented improvement on the gaff (a spar used in sailing) of a French schooner, Alcyon, which had docked in Boston. The improvement had been installed in France, where it was legal.

---

This image was created with Leonardo.ai.

This image was created with Leonardo.ai.

Copyright: Protecting Creativity While Enriching Culture

Copyright law is a prime example of utilitarianism in action. By giving creators exclusive rights to their original works—whether it’s a song, a book, or a painting—copyright incentivizes artistic expression.

Creators know they can reap the rewards of their labor, and this assurance fuels cultural innovation. But here’s the key: copyright isn’t forever. It generally lasts for the life of the creator plus 70 years, which ensures a balance:

• For the Creator: They receive recognition and financial benefit during their lifetime.
  
• For Society: After the protection period, works enter the public domain, enriching collective knowledge and sparking new creations.

This balance creates a cycle of creation and dissemination, ensuring a thriving cultural landscape where new ideas constantly emerge.

---

This balance creates a cycle of creation and dissemination, ensuring a thriving cultural landscape where new ideas constantly emerge.

Patents: Driving Technological Innovation

Similar to copyright, patent law is rooted in utilitarian principles. Inventors are granted exclusive rights to their inventions for a limited period—usually 20 years—allowing them to recoup their investments and profit from their hard work.

Why does this matter?

• Encourages Innovation: Knowing their inventions are protected, inventors are more likely to take risks and push boundaries.
• Benefits Society: Patents spur groundbreaking advancements, from life-saving medicines to revolutionary tech. Once the patent expires, these innovations enter the public domain, enabling further development and competition.

The utilitarian approach ensures a win-win: inventors get rewarded, and society benefits from improved technologies.

Striking the Perfect Balance

The brilliance of the U.S. IP system lies in its ability to balance:

• Protecting creators and inventors so they can thrive.
• Ensuring that their contributions eventually benefit everyone.

Copyright and patent laws work together to maintain this equilibrium, fostering a culture where innovation and creativity are both encouraged and accessible.

This image was created with FreePik.

This image was created with Leonardo.ai.